Interrogating Spaces
Interrogating Spaces is a podcast that examines ideas around inclusivity in Higher Education. Each episode will explore democratic and decolonised teaching practices through dialogue with practitioners as well as staff and students from University of the Arts London. This podcast is brought to you from the Teaching and Learning Directorate at UAL.
Interrogating Spaces
Walking Pedagogies: Brixton and Windrush Square with Rahul Patel and Dr Gurnam Singh
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Rahul Patel takes Dr Gurnam Singh on a walk around key monuments and buildings in Windrush Square in Brixton, South London, where he grew up. Through these key sites we learn about the often-overlooked contributions of the Windrush generation to British society as well as the barriers and discrimination that Black communities have faced, particularly in terms of education. The points on the walk mark key events that led to the 1981 uprisings that demonstrated against the prevalent structural racial inequality in Britain.
Walking pedagogies is a series of audio dialogues exploring pedagogy through conversation and walking. The project brings UAL staff and practitioners together to curate and lead meaningful walks rooted in specific locations to share personal context and history. Drawing on walking ethnographic practice and psychogeography, these recordings become unique records of what it is to be a teacher in this moment in time. They take us out of the university to encounter in wider environmental and political contexts and issues.
For more information visit: https://walkingpedagogies.myblog.arts.ac.uk/
Rahul Patel teaches on both the MA and BA Culture, Criticism and Curation programmes at Central Saint Martins and has initiated numerous Transformative Pedagogies programmes including Reading Collections, Decolonising the Arts Curriculum zines and Frantz Fanon’s Black Skin, White Masks. Interpretations, Art and Pedagogy.
Dr Gurnam Singh is currently Professor of Sociology at Warwick University and was previously Visiting Fellow in Race and Education at UAL.
Gemma Riggs is Resource Developer within UAL’s Learning and Teaching Directorate and a practicing artist and filmmaker.
Walking Pedagogies has been prodced by the Learning and Teaching Directorate at the University of the Arts London. For more materials exploring pedagogy at UAL visit: www.arts.ac.uk/about-ual/learning-and-teaching/resources
Gemma Riggs 00:02
This is Walking Pedagogies, a series of walking conversations that explore personal narratives around pedagogy and social justice. In this episode, Rahul Patel takes Dr. Gurnam Singh on a walk around the key monuments and buildings in Windrush Square in Brixton, South London, they tell the stories of the injustices faced by the Windrush generation and the uprisings that came about. The walk starts in the northeasterly corner of the square near the African and Caribbean War Memorial.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 00:35
So, my name is Gurnam Singh. I'm a visiting fellow in race and education at the University of Arts London, and I'm delighted to be involved with the Walking Pedagogies project.
Rahul Patel 00:46
My name is Rahul Patel. I'm a lecturer at the University of the Arts London, predominantly in culture and cultural history, and art and history as well.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 00:56
So frequently described as Little Jamaica, our Walking Pedagogies session today brings us to Brixton, in the South London borough of Lambeth. Like many areas, Brixton has undergone many transformations during the past few eras. But it was after World War II that Brixton saw the arrival of what is known as the Windrush generation, and indeed we are stood in Windrush Square at the moment. So Rahul, just let's begin. What's the Windrush generation?
Rahul Patel 01:25
The Windrush generation is you can if you want to put a date to it. It's 1948, where we had a ship called the Empire Windrush, SS Windrush, and we are in the middle of the square where we see very clearly etched sandstone SS Windrush. This was a significant moment because this was the time when Britain went to the West Indies. This was after the Second World War, it was desperate for labour, and it needed people to come and work in its dilapidated factories, public transport, in order for Britain to come out the war proper. And it recruited people in their 10s, hundreds, and 1000s to come and work here, and the Empire Windrush was the first ship, symbolically, that docked in Tilbury. And since then, we use the term the Windrush generation. It's it's only been a recent, when I say recent, in the last 20 odd years that the term has been used. But before that, it was always seen as Caribbean immigration coming to Britain, and that was the language that was that that was used.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 02:51
And of course, in the context of today, the Windrush generation also represents the scandal, the dehumanization of those people, many of whom are still to this very day seen as alien, seen as in fact you know subject to deportation orders and compensation seeking compensation, but you mentioned the kind of the pull or the drawing in of migrant labourers. There were other groups of black people from the Caribbean, from Africa, who served the British not just in the factories, London Transport, but even before that in the two wars, and we're actually stood in front of a war memorial. You're
Rahul Patel 03:30
absolutely right, Gurnam, because you know the the history, the formal history of Britain is that black people came in 1948 onwards, right? Black and brown people came after that, but in fact, obviously the links, even for Brixton and Lambeth, go back to slavery, right? And before slavery as well. And here we are in front of a memorial, two obelisk. We have a triangular sandstone memorial, and it is in memory of servicemen and women from Africa and the Caribbean who served alongside the forces of the British Commonwealth and our allies during World War One and World War Two, and it says at the bottom in in in lower case sorry not in lower case but in smaller font remembering the forgotten and this is very very important. I mean, this was put up fairly recently in 2017, and every year West Indian servicemen, as they call, and and there are only few started around now. We have a memorial day every year, and this this particular memorial is here because there is no memorial in central London to the black soldiers who fought in the First World War. There is the typical divide and rule for the British because actually Indian service. Were allowed to march on that victory parade in 1918, but African soldiers or black soldiers were not, and there was a conscious attempt to not have them on the victory parade. And here it took after decades and decades of historical, because what it required was historical archive research to bring out the poignant figures, and then then to get the authority to say we needed a memorial here, and it was symbolically put here in Windrose Square, and here we have all the campaigns that they were involved in, and it's sort of and and and and we need to look at the scale of of what it says here as well. Over 2 million men provided in the two world wars from Botswana, Kenya, Lesotho, Malawi, South Africa, Swaziland, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia, and Zimbabwe, and here we have the regiment from Ghana as well, and then West Africa, Cameroon, and then we go across to the Caribbean as well.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 06:14
Phenomenal! You've got you know an army of 2 million serving the two wars, and then if you kind of begin to add the kind of within the Indian context. You had almost up to 4 million. The truth is, Britain would not have survived without the contribution of black people in fighting those two world wars. But that history, that contribution, is often erased quite deliberately as well.
Rahul Patel 06:38
And and this is on on the poignant point, remembering the forgotten, and at the bottom of the second obelisk is God and to all the forgotten, and that is very important. But the thing that sticks out to me here to make it relevant for today, because this square is relevant even in today's campaign. It's not historical memorials that you find in central London, kind of dusty old men on pedestals. Here is a living embodiment of what British society is even today, which is which is about war. It's about colonialism and colonial narration in all its form. And here you see the word Palestine engraved on these obliques as well, and for me, there is a war taking place against Gaza at the moment by the Israeli, as I call it, occupying forces, and supported by the same imperial powers of those days. And I read an article, a very small article in the Guardian, that the Israeli Defense Forces, occupying forces, bombed a memorial grave to the Commonwealth soldiers and totally flattened it, and so here we have the links about what's taking place.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 07:54
And these, of course, have many ironies that we will be discussing today. We're going to go over to the Black Cultural Archives now, because that's also a significant landmark, a significant presence. It actually was established back in 1981, soon after the Brixton uprising that we'll be talking about. That, and it was established by, as I say, by a well-known historian and educationist, for example, Len Garrison, and it contains all the archives around the kind of uprising, the riots, and we're going to talk about that. But we were saying that you know the but the black people from the Caribbean came to Brixton in the 50s, the Windrush, and you know they came with fanfare, with you know, kind of calypso music, everything's happy, and of course, they brought the culture, music, traditions, and you know, and it's made what Brixton is today. But it, but they also faced untold racism, you know, institutionalized racism, violence from the far right, police brutality, and we'll be touching on all those things. But if we're thinking about the education field, you know, Brixton is about challenging the kind of racism within the education system. Of course, there was a very important publication by Bernard Coard, a Grenadian-born educationalist, called ‘How the West Indian Child Is Made Educationally Subnormal in the British School system’. This was published in 1971. In some senses, this predates the kind of anti-racist education, multicultural education, and it was a damn indictment as to how the education system was actually destroying black people, black young people. It was turning them into into pathologically kind of damaged people. Educationally Subnormal. What was this? What was this report about? What was the significance of this?
Rahul Patel 09:49
So it was about the scandal of the black child in schools in Britain. That is what this pamphlet or this small publication produced. How the West Indian Child is Made Educationally Subnormal in the British School System, and it was produced by New Beacon School, New Beacon Books, and published for the Caribbean Education and Community Workers Association, and they played a central role in in in bringing the scandal into the open about how the black child was treated in the British education system, they were classified as educationally subnormal. But all all all the tropes of black people over the number over the number of centuries through slavery, colonialism, imperialism, and what was then seen as post post imperialism was focused on the black child. Yeah, and
Dr. Gurnam Singh 10:47
today we are. I mean, in higher education, we talk about the B A M E attainment gap, awarding gap, and some some of those same tropes around you know kind of deficit modelling. And there's a connection between Coard's research and his theories, if you like, and actually the kind of the discussions we're having in higher education today.
Rahul Patel 11:09
Absolutely, absolutely, and and and and we go back where, when we talk about the memoirs as not to be forgotten, what we link in terms of education is that black people's history was totally forgotten, and that played a central role within the education system because what was deprived from them was their own history, and and that played a critical role in the kind of the context of daily education. So we have to go through that. I think we need to go through that Bernard Coard moment in higher education in Britain as well. In higher education, there's an absolutely long way to go in relation to this. Now, we are talking about the Black Cultural Archives. We are standing on one part of Windrush Square, and there's a straight kind of small road, paved small road, and for me this is a really important what I would call pedagogical road, because we have the archive. The archive is about historical narration, rediscovering yourself, looking at the intricacies of your your past in the way that is not taught in the education system, but then further down you have Brixton Library, and for me Brixton Library is what I would call the living embodiment of a narration of of black people's education, and we'll talk about that later.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 12:41
Of course, we talk about the work of people like Paulo Freire in the ‘Pedagogy of the oppressed’. In some senses, this whole space from the library to the archive itself is a testament to the way in which, for black people, education has been a political question. It's been a question of struggle. For example, this archive itself was established off the back of the work of the Brixton Defense Campaign, which was formed by the Brixton Black Women's Group and Black People Against State Harassment. So that's where it comes from. It's a kind of praxis. It's coming from real struggles, and you know the archive is an amazing collection. I know that we've got books in in the library itself that are maybe out of print now, not accessible. And you know, archiving that history, curating that history, is really important, isn't it, in terms of political struggles and today?
Rahul Patel 13:38
Absolutely. See, people's kind of overall notions of archives are dusty old rooms, right? Inaccessible material, but here we have in Black cultural archives what Stuart Hall called a living embodiment. It has to be a living, thriving archive, because the archives have to be reinterpreted in the context of our lives today, what we kind of fixed and how we kind of saw even something five years ago is not necessarily something we would see through the archives through today's lenses. Because the forces who are attempting to shape history, our rulers, have a different notion, and here we are rediscovering continually our our history. So, if we look at at we are the archive is closed today, but one day we will go go in there. But if you look even outside, we see a installation. It's a metal installation of a very very important figure, crucial figure, and her name is Claudia Claudia Vera Jones. Yeah, Claudia Vera Jones is known for for setting up of the Notting Hill Carnival, the Europe's largest street festival, but. The story behind Claudia Jones needs to be heard. Claudia Jones was removed from America because she was a member of the of the American Communist Party. She was pushed out because of McCarthyism, the witch hunts, as they were called then. And Claudia then came to Britain, and she started a newspaper, and she started organizing workers. For her, that was important: organizing workers. And obviously, the history of the Nottingham Carnival is is there. We can talk about it some other time. But what's important is that Black Cultural Archives found a place for Claudia Vera Jones, but the interesting fact that people don't talk about even today is that Claudia Vera Jones is buried next to Karl Marx in Highgate Cemetery.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 15:54
That's a really important point that I wanted to underline. There's this sense that you know black people engage in anti-racist struggles, of course they do, but they've also been actively involved in class struggle as well. We can go back to the Chartists, you know, people like William Cuffy and others, you know, up to Claudia James, Richard Wright, and many, many more. And I think that, you know, in some senses, I think in today's kind of framing of anti-racism, we've kind of lost sight of the fact that you know anti-racist struggles were always struggles about the liberation of working people, of working-class people, and race and class was very much seen as part of the same challenge.
Rahul Patel 16:32
Absolutely, because see the the the issue of identity has been brought into this discussion, and and it has two faces, right? Okay, we need identity to discover ourselves, discover our sense of history, identity that's removed. But what we've also got is the right wing clearly using identity for its own particular purposes. So it's interesting that we we rightly talk about indigenous Indigenous people in North and South Americas. We talk about them in Australia. We talk about them in different parts of the world. But the right wing here have started talking about the indigenous people. But for them, the Indigenous people are white people on the basis of a kind of a false history that they're bringing up, because there's never a case that Britain was always white. Britain has always been a place of of of migration.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 17:31
Well, absolutely, and you know we talk about decoloniality and decolon. I mean, historically, anti-colonial struggles were all always about justice, about you know materiality. They weren't necessarily about culture or about politics of identity, and in some senses, I think some of the struggles have got confused. But we're now moving towards the center of the square, and we've got some more really important aspects to talk about.
Rahul Patel 17:55
See, I think, and we do need to talk about this: is the Uprisings
Dr. Gurnam Singh 18:02
up from the. You know,
Rahul Patel 18:04
1981 was the Uprisings, and it wasn't just Brixton, by the way, right? And Brixton is famous for that, but it spread.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 18:11
It began here,
Rahul Patel 18:13
of course. Of course, of course, of course, and it began. It began not in 1981. It began. It began the the previous decade.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 18:24
New Cross was the important trigger. New Cross fire, 18th of January 1981. New Cross is what about five miles from here, when 13 black young people lost their lives in a fire. The Metropolitan Police mishandled the investigation, the community were convinced that this was a racist hate crime, and I know that on the on the 2nd of March 1981, there was a huge demonstration. I can remember that demonstration. People like Darcus Howe and others, and it was the Black People's Day of Action, and it's really off the back of of that incident, then we began then, and of course the other context was police SUS laws, where the police would, you know, without any kind of reason whatsoever, go into black communities, just on the basis that they suspected somebody might be committing a crime, and Brixton was one of those areas where the police were very active in doing their raids, going in and going out. Yeah. So that was the context of what happened. And then tell me about then where what happened then after that. I
Rahul Patel 19:28
mean, the decade. I I was here. I was I was in Brixton. I've lived in Brixton since 1970. And what we had was that black people were seen as muggers. Black people were picked up as drug dealers. Yeah. Right. This was rampant, and it was it it was then really it it was toxicized, if you like to call it, when Margaret. She made a speech in 1978 when she said, "Now she directed this against Asian people coming into the country. She used the term "we've been swamped by an alien culture.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 20:13
That was in 19. That was in 1978. I think it was on the ‘World in Action’ on the Granada. Granada
Rahul Patel 20:18
‘World in Action’ programme. She said that when she said we've been swamped, the police forces in in Lambeth in Brixton in 1981 in April when the uprising occurred started an operation called Operation Swamp. Right. So there's the two linking of the words. They were very conscious of that word. Right, and that's why the police called it. So they started this about a typical day's operation, stopping literally every young black man on Ralton Road, which is not far from here, and Coldharbour Lane. This is less than half a mile away here, where where where it first started off, so there's a kind of a conscious element constantly from our politicians. At that time, Margaret Thatcher got elected as the first Conservative minister for that decade, and it started it. And the uprising led had said after the New Cross massacre, but quite clearly said we have had enough, and we're challenging the. But the
Dr. Gurnam Singh 21:25
economics at the time was important because Thatcher's policy was to destroy the trade unions, and the way she did that was to create mass unemployment. And of course, black black people. I mean, I've read some statistics that almost 60% of black young people were jobless in and around Brixton, so there was this sense that you know economically you were being exploited or oppressed, and and what else could you do but was hang around the streets and the police were coming in, and attacking it. There was this sense of being under siege, and then, as we know, on the weekend of the 10th to the 12th of April, 1981. Everything kind of you know held that loose, as it were.
Rahul Patel 22:06
Yeah, absolutely. Look, see, my schooling was in this area, and when I when I went to secondary school, our first school visit was to A you know to to a youth prison in Rochester on just off the A2, and when we went there, I went to a predominantly black school. I was the only, if you like to call it, the Asian Asian student there. 80% of the of the it was just a boys' school, and 80% of of the boys were black, 20% of white working class. We were taken to a borstal. That's what it was called. And when I when we were set in the the kind of the main meeting room, the governor came up and then pointed to us at the field, which goes down towards Rochester. This is the Rochester Hills, and some people might recognize as they're driving past. And there were two horses in in the field. There was a black horse and a white horse, and the Governor. And I'm now apologize for this absolutely disgusting racist language, but I need to say this: he turned round and said, because we had windows, said, "Do you see that horse? That's chalky. And then he turned round and says, "Do you see the other one? A black horse, and that
Dr. Gurnam Singh 23:37
is Coon.
Rahul Patel 23:38
And that was from the establishment, and we here we have a young group of black men being told this in front with a senior leading figure in terms of what was happening. I was I was born in Africa. I was born in Kenya. I was brought up with black people, but I've never heard that sort of language, and even at a young, young, young person at the age of 11, 12, I was shocked that someone who we had to revere, a white person, could use language like
Dr. Gurnam Singh 24:14
that. Language. I mean, I grew up around the same time up in the north, and it was the same. I mean, and in some senses, what was really interesting about that kind of racial language, although it might have been might have come out of certain stereotypes around certain people, black people, Asian people, it was it was always free-floating signifiers. So you know, I was called a coon, coon, and I was called a black bastard. I was called a Wog. I was called a Paki, and all sorts of other things. But it was out of that sense of we're all kind of in it together that we had a black collective, you know, kind of political. And we talked about that in a previous Walking Pedagogies talk, where it was about black people uniting. Yes, it's about black Caribbean people, black. African people, but we were all black in those days.
Rahul Patel 25:03
Absolutely, we were politically black, and we were very strong as a result of that, right? And obviously, there's been a debate, discussion about what that kind of entails, what it means, who's left in, who's left out. But coming back to the Uprising, it was a shock to the British ruling class because it spread from Brixton right up to Toxteth in Liverpool, to Bristol, to Newcastle, to Coventry, to Birmingham, all aspects of Britain. This this Uprising happened, and it was it wasn't just black people actually. It was young black and white people together because unemployment was faced by both groups of people, and there was a very, very strong affinity of both black and white people. Now, what came out of what what what they termed as the Brixton Disorders was the the Home Secretary at the time, William Whitelaw, immediately launched a public inquiry. The Public Inquiry. If you think of this, this is probably the fastest reporting of any Public Inquiry. The the disorders, as they call them, occurred on the 10th to the 12th of April 1981, right? And the report was produced in November 1981. We look at all the inquiries now, from Grenfell to the Horizon Post Office, it's taking decades in terms of reporting our Bloody Sunday. You know, there's a whole number of inquiries. Why? Because they were absolutely shocked as, in fact, what was in fact taking place. But interesting, when you look, and I think it's worth looking at this. Very, very. This is the Home Office report. Darcus Howe. Darcus as how at that time, and he was right to say this. This doesn't. This report did not produce any solutions for black people, in any in any way possible. But when you when, but when you look at this report, when you look at this report, the report itself took evidence from round the world, from America. It took from Dane County Citizens Committee because of the disorders that occurred in Florida. And what? But we remember our pedagogies walk started off in Southall, and they took a report from a Southall as well, from the Friends of Blair Peach, in terms of what was in fact taking place. So you look at this; they even talked talked to Darcus Howe in Race Today, in terms of what's taking place. New Jersey Disorder. So here they took important evidence. They took important cultural evidence as well in terms of a whole series of things, but the conclusions were very wanting. But the one thing I would do want to say is, you had to read between the lines, and some people read between the lines and then decided to take some action on this. And on education, we return to the word to the the whole issue of education. What Scarman says is in relation to the education. He says there should be a broad education in humanities designed to help the various ethnic groups, including the host community, to understand each other's culture, background, and culture, and the basic training and skills necessary to obtain work in the technological economy of the modern world, and methods, and this is probably the most important part of it, including a revolution in curriculum to deal with these problems. I've been developed and put into operation, and he talked about the sense of worth, the sense of history, been missing in the curriculum, and it was through this that gave a very powerful force in a kind of a structural sense to the Bernard Coard report, because then the Greater London Authority and the local authorities then structuralizes this into an anti-racist education pedagogy. That led
Dr. Gurnam Singh 29:06
to the birth of the anti-racist education movement. Although I wouldn't credit Scarman for that. What's interesting about Scarman's report as well? This is the first time that, in a government report, the word institutionalised racism appears. Although, ironically, Scarman actually said that the Metropolitan Police was not institutionally racist, although most people thought that he he did, which is interesting because when we get to the Stephen Lawrence inquiry, again the same kind of question is raised, and this time the Met did acknowledge that they were institutionalists, although later they even kind of went back on that, and even to this day we've still got the.
Gemma Riggs 29:48
go back through the square towards Efra Road, where we stop at a monument to Cherry Groce. The monument is made of polished concrete with triangular shapes that offer a shelter. Canopy for visitors to sit under.
Rahul Patel 30:02
So, so the whole issue of of also Brixton is the question of deaths in custody. So, black people being been banged up by the police and then dying in custody. And here we are at the Memorial of Cherry Groce. We're not. We're looking not in 1981, but a subsequent uprising that occurred in 1985, and how wide did this occur? Because the police bursted in to the home of Cherry Groce and shot her. They were looking for one of our sons, which which they assumed to be in this country illegally, right? And they shot her. And it was that the second uprising occurred. This memorial was only recently put up. It was only put up two years ago, and here you see in the middle of Windrush Square various memorials put up. This is not a kind of a design, well-designed, thought-out like Trafalgar Square or something like that. Here we have people pushing forward their history from below, and and here is a memorial created, set up, and instituted by her son Lee
Dr. Gurnam Singh 31:06
Lawrence. She was paralysed by the shooting.
Gemma Riggs 31:11
Moving further towards the centre of Windrush Square, we find a memorial to the Sharpeville massacre, where people protesting against apartheid were openly fired upon by police in Sharpeville, South Africa.
Rahul Patel 31:24
So here we have again in Windrush Square, we have a memorial to the Sharpeville massacre that occurred on the 21st of March 1960, and here we have a kind of a brutalist, very small concrete installation, and we have a stainless-steel plate which says ‘Sharpeville, 21st March 1960’. They died, so the others may live. But what I find about Windrose Square is all of this is very decontextualized. There's not an explanation. I think a lot of young people today, but also older people, would not know what this is about. It is sitting in this square where every day people just walk by it, and and and and here we have this. But it's important that we remember that Sharpeville again had a big impact on the community here. We talked about the 50s and 60s, and this is symbolic about international solidarity that has played a crucial role in what's taking place.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 32:29
And it's worth mentioning Archbishop Trevor Huddleston, who was one of the leading campaigners against the apartheid in South Africa. So it was always seen as a friend of the black community, if you like, and this is dedicated to him as well. And just behind
Rahul Patel 32:45
us is a wonderful tree, absolutely wonderful tree. This tree has become a symbol of resistance in so many ways. The most recent one was for Palestine, ironically enough, where in 2021, when Israel bombed Gaza, it always bombs Gaza, but nothing new. But again, 2,000 Palestinians died in that. This tree was festooned with minor Palestinian flags, all right, and there was a cat and mouse game with the council. The council had to play a big operation in taking it down. If you think of it, you need a cherry picker, get it through each branch of the tree. It's a very very large tree, and they had to take it down. The activists would then put it up again, and there was a cat and mouse game around very small flags festooned in there, so this is a square for resistance. So we're now going to move to another piece here, and this is a statue, a sort of a headstone of Sir Henry Tate, and so we know Henry Tate through the Tate galleries, Tate Britain, Tate Modern,
Dr. Gurnam Singh 34:06
and Tate and Lyle Sugar Corporation.
Rahul Patel 34:08
Absolutely. So Tate and Lyle Sugar Corporation, and he saw himself as a philanthropist. He was from Lambeth, right? He was from Lambeth, and just behind us we see the Tate Library. So he donated his money from the sugar plantations to philanthropy for local people. It has taken activists a long period of time to to pull out and ask of the estate of Henry Tate, Sir Henry Tate, that there was some sort of an involvement by by Tate in the context of slavery, because what they come out with is, and I've been to several meetings in Brixton Library where people will be talking about slavery. And they would have two lawyers from the Tate and Lyle firm saying at the back, anyone said Tate and Lyle was involved in slavery, they'll get up and say, sorry, no, he was not involved in slavery. He had sugar plantations, but he was not involved in sugar in that. That has now changed through the Black Lives Matter movement, Tate, and through the decolonisation movement, the Tate, both the Tate galleries, have put a statement up, and quite clearly saying what the links are between Henry Tate, slavery, and his philanthropy, and that should be shown.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 35:40
There's an interest in politics there because if we think about the Edward Colson statue in Bristol, which it was connected to the Black Lives Matter movement following the murder of George Floyd, you find a similar kind of debate that had been taking place. That Colson was this great philanthropist. He he donated. He'd built schools. He built hospitals. Yet also Colson made his millions off the back of slavery, and then when they had the abolition of slavery, it was people like Colson that that that you know made millions of pounds, and and then you had this kind of irony where these former slave owners or these businesses and corporations awash with money from slavery, not knowing what to do with it, and then become philanthropists, and it raises these interesting questions as to whether you should take money that's been, you know, accrued from these kinds of, you know, inhumane kind of histories, you know.
Rahul Patel 36:35
So I've got a photograph in front of me here, and this event takes place around the first of August, the first Saturday of the first of August every year. And what is it? It's Africa Day. It's Reparations Day. And here we have a photograph of this very statue, this installation, this headstone of Henry Tate, being covered by a piece of cloth, right, and to say we no longer need him, we don't want his voice in Windrush Square, and I think this is so symbolic. This is so wonderfully done in that sense because this is another way of bringing the statues down, right? And this is done very, very cleverly by a group of activists to say we don't. We don't. I
Dr. Gurnam Singh 37:36
think this is a very interesting act of recuration, if you like, curating them differently, and that's a different conversation to have. Whether by removing the statues, in a sense, you you erase their crimes, or whether we need to keep the statues there but tell people exactly what crimes they committed.
Rahul Patel 37:54
And so here we have we we're going into Brixton Library. I would say it's an activist library. I think the librarians want to make sure that the living histories of people who have been removed from histories are are at the central of of of narration on a daily basis, but it's not just Black History. We have LGBT+ histories, and they celebrate what, in fact, is taking place.
Gemma Riggs 38:31
We enter Brixton Library and move through the atrium into one of the quiet reading rooms, where a number of portraits are displayed high on the walls above the library shelves.
Rahul Patel 38:42
Very. important portraits, right in the main library, of of activists who have played a central role in both second places. We have Linton Kwesi Johnson there, right? Here we have Bernie Grant on on here. My my task is that none of the act none of the portraitures have names on it, and my task and my working with the library is that I'm going to produce a booklet which actually contextualizes all of them. So here we have in the middle, we have three portraits of activists in the early 70s who were part of the British Black Panther Party, right? You have Leila (Hassan Howe), you have Darcus (Howe), and Farraukh (Dhondy). I don't want to concentrate on Leila or Darcus. That's another time. I want to concentrate on this man here, Farrukh Dhondy. Farrukh Dhondy was my teacher at school. He was my English teacher, and for me, he played a crucial role in his pedagogic development about what should be a class. Yeah, so I I was moved from a secondary modern school to a comprehensive school. So what was so important there were the teachers. The teachers were crucial, and I I was so so so lucky that I ended up with probably the most fantastic teacher going, and his name was Farrukh Dhondy, and we had two English teachers. Farrukh was one of them. The other teacher, I can't even remember her name. Actually, it's terrible, but I can't remember her name after whatever 50 years. The other teacher, we had Shakespeare. We had Shakespeare in a totally inaccessible way. Shakespeare is fantastic, but there was no contextualization. We were we were forced to read by root, right? And and and for us, in a working class environment, we just had no connection at all. Yeah, you know, absolutely. But Farrukh turned it the other way around. He came in. He had the swagger. He did have the swagger, right? He came in. He wore an Afghan, right? I don't know whether you know what these Afghan coats were like. He came in with an Afghan. He had a man bag, which no one, you know, is like something completely different was seen as effeminate in in his kind of posturing, and that he had a kind of way of relating to students that immediately focused on on what it was. And he came in one day. Remember this. I will never forget this. He came in one day with a record player. Remember those things? Those record players, and he, and and and he just threw that on the table. He said, "Right, we're going to play this, and he says, "I went to see him last night, and it was he was inspiration, right? And here's his record. So we kind of us us kids at what 1112, 13, or whatever. You know, we'd never been to a concert, right? We'd never been to a concert or anything like that, and we didn't know what he was talking about. And it was Bob Dylan. He brought Bob Dylan, and and he played. He played. Oh God! What was this song? Blowing in the wind. Blowing in the wind, and he went through that line by line, replayed the verse line by line. I've never seen so. You know, we had a class of what 25 odd, right? Totally engrossed, listening line by line, and Dylan was sung years after, right? Okay, but it wasn't a black artist. I didn't know at that time. I did not know at the time that actually Linton Kwesi Johnson was a was was a very good friend of Farrukh Dhondy, and they were political activists together in the Black Panther Party. But it's just how, in a little way, right? They totally overturned the kind of the discussion what was taking place. So, blowing in the wind was about changing society, changing and running a revolution. That immediately the students were focused on that rather than Shakespeare is about revolution, but it was done in a dry, turgid way that had no connection with people's lives, and this had a people's lives. So that was one aspect of it, and which I'll never forget.
Gemma Riggs 43:31
Moving on through the library and heading towards the conclusion of our walk, we hear about black empowerment through scholarship and intellectual activism that flourished in Brixton.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 43:42
So there are many ways in which you can resist oppression and racism, and of course, what we found in 1981, the Brixton uprising, was direct action. Self-defence is no is no offense, and we and that was demonstrated across the country. But another way in which you can resist, and we talked about the Coard, his book, is by developing your own narrative, developing your own research, developing your own press and publications. And one of the things that we found in Brixton was the the emergence of black scholarship, the Race Today Collective. You know, we're stood in the library at the moment, and we can talk about some of the collections here, but just tell us a bit about the Race Today collective and and that whole kind of moment with people like Darcus Howe and and Farrukh Dhony as well. He was also part of that.
Rahul Patel 44:34
Yeah. See, the road that we need to refer to is Railton Road. Yeah, the Brixton Advice
Dr. Gurnam Singh 44:42
Centre. Yeah,
Rahul Patel 44:43
yeah, Brixton Advice Centre. But the but this but it started not of Darcus Howe and the Race Today collective. They were central to it. But there was one other individual that played a significant role before them and plays a significant role now. Unfortunately, has died.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 45:11
Linton Kwesi Johnson
Rahul Patel 45:12
No, not only did Linton Kwesi Johnson. It's funny. Linton Kwesi Johnson is on the opposite side a bit. C. L. R. James.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 45:18
Oh yes, of course. So
Rahul Patel 45:19
C. L. R. James lived in Brixton. He lived in on Ralton Road, and his book ‘The Black Jacobians’ which is in the Black Cultural Archives, been sold today as well. Played a significant role in reappraising the imperial narration of that whole that whole context of, if you like to call it, the Enlightenment project, right? Okay, because that was challenged from the his his book, the Black Jacobians, was a seminal research project. C. L. R. James researched that in in in in Paris actually in 19. It was published in 1938. Not much notice been taken, but when he came back, when he came to Britain from the Caribbean, that book started to have a resonance, especially in the context of education, in the first the first ever successful Slave Revolution, and for those group of activists, C. L. R. James was the connection between an understanding of history, and this is important. That's always forgotten: an understanding of of history through class, through a framework of Marxism, because C. L. R. James saw himself as a Marxist, and it was his framework that that played a key role in the book, The Black Jacobians. And so here was a was a setup of Race Today. We need publications. We need a collective that talks about our struggles, but it also contextualizes it in a daily historical context. And the Race Today Collective played a seminal role in terms of their publications and provided a focus for a group of activists to kind of frame what was important. And of
Dr. Gurnam Singh 47:19
course, the central character in C. L. R James's book, Black Jacobins, is Toussaint L'Ouverture, who led the Haitian Revolution against French imperial rule. Now, what's interesting is that for people don't know, the Jacobins were the French revolutionaries that overthrew the Bastille, and C.L. R. James is saying that there were, you know, talking about black Jacobins, that in fact the Haitian Revolution was itself partly a revolution, you know, against the ruling elites, and you know, people like Toussaint L’Ouverture were inspired by those very same French revolutionary ideals. In some senses, it was those ideals that inspired the revolution, and this is interesting in the sense that we talked earlier about politics of identity. This wasn't a politics of identity. This was a politics of, you know, restructuring a state. Actually, it was very much rooted in the kind of liberation struggles that were taking place across Europe. You know, it's important to recognize that as well, and that's why C. L. R. James and his critique, and in fact the critique of the Race Today Collective, was always closely aligned to a class analysis. You know, you couldn't do race without doing class, and that's why they had another journal which was the Race and Class. You know, and the Race Today people were, you know, connecting the two. Really important to keep that connection going.
Rahul Patel 48:46
Absolutely, and I think the we come back to pedagogy. What do we mean by pedagogy, right? Because we are we are kind of framed in our university environment that only there pedagogy takes place, right? Only there the learning processes are understood. Only there learning processes are discovered. Only there that supreme knowledge can be configured, right? And here we have pedagogy, not just of the oppressed, but pedagogy from below, right? Pedagogy from a group of people who weren't who didn't necessarily see themselves as oppressed, but but also saw themselves of a of a part of a solution of saying we no longer want this to continue through centuries and centuries, and we want a totally new society, and that's what it was configured towards. So C. L. R. James was playing an important part in that, and so was the Race Today Collective, and also a whole number of other organizations.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 49:49
And in this library where we are here at the moment, and we're celebrating, you know, Black History, and we do that every year. It's really important note to that the abstract Black. From world history, black history and world history are part of the same thing, and you know black people's struggles against oppression are not just configured through their racialisation, but they're configured through struggles against women's oppression, disability rights activism, and in this library, actually, you've got you know all the kind of different, you know, you've got the LGBT+ activist movement posters here, and resources, and those connections are really important, aren't the connections?
Rahul Patel 50:30
I certainly think so. So, I mean, if there's a, I mean, we're in Southall, and a kind of comparison is that here there's quite a clear conscious attempt, and still a conscious attempt, that we need a place of learning, right? A place where ordinary young people, older people, can come. I mean, at the moment, this there's a building work taking place in this library upstairs. But when I normally come, I will never find a seat here, right? It's packed, packed out, and packed out seven days a week, right? From nine in the morning till throwout time, this library has become a real sense of saying we want this. This is our place of learning, and and and and the librarians have made a conscious attempt to actually bring in knowledge, books, and other artifacts within here. They also bring in, as you as we saw in in some of the television screens and the posters, bring in authors, living authors, right, who can then talk through what's taking place? And the last time I was here, I was here for a talk by Hew Locke. Now, Hew Locke is a fantastic artist. He did a fantastic installation at the Tate. I don't know whether you saw it. It was the middle gallery of the Tate, where he took imperial figures in horses and all sorts of clothing. I'll show you, and I'll give you photographs for this. Right, what the library did was they removed all of these books. You know, I noticed they're on wheels, so they removed all of this, and this whole place was packed with Hew Locke coming to speak. And this is how busy it is, and I think it's interesting because we have a different argument at at our university libraries. Our university libraries are made up of staff who are exclusively white, right? Okay, and I've said this to management at even at Central Saint Martins. You you have the time I've been there, since quite a long time at Central Saint Martins, I haven't seen a black person working in this library, right? It is, you know. So it's a university library in the heart of central London, right? And they don't have a black person working here. Here, 75% of the staff here are black. There's a black library manager, right? And you have a sense in which history-not only just black history, but history in a cultural or artistic sense-plays a significant role.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 53:14
I mean, in some sense, if we talk about decolonisation, you know, you have to decolonize both the creation of, as it were, literature and knowledge, and you have to decolonise the curation of literature and knowledge if you really want to be serious. And you know, here's a good example as to how you can achieve both with limited resources. Just one other thing: I talked about the the the the Race Today Collective. You know, we talked earlier on about the importance of archiving material, but what what what they were doing, and I'm thinking about in Southall with the Southwell monitoring group doing the same, was that they were actually recording police violence. They were recording racist attacks because the state would refuse to do that, and one of the archives that was created was the deaths of black people in custody. Each year, they would publish. This is significant because, over the decades, you know, you're talking in the hundreds, if not the 1000s, of black people dying in custody. In fact, there was some recent research then that black men are seven times more likely to die in police custody than white men, and so you know this is important because if we think about some of the riots, some of the uprisings, you know Cynthia Jarrett, they've come out of the deaths of people in custody, and you know we talk about Blair Peach, he wasn't in custody, but he was at the hands of the police, and I think it's really important. We we you know we had the kind of after after George Floyd was murdered, you know everybody was up in you know we've got to do something. This is terrible. A black man dying in police. It was terrible, but actually this wasn't new. It hasn't been new. You know, and and you know deaths of black people in custody are often associated with then the community responding. You know we had that in Tottenham, and you know that's a whole history in itself.
Rahul Patel 55:04
It is, but I mean, since the and it's important to talk about Black Lives Matter and and the murder of George Floyd because I do remember. Again, we come to Windrush Square, and in Windrush Square, I remember on on the seventh of June we called a protest. We would take the knee, and we had 1000 people in Windows Square, just where we walked through with the bits of grass and everything like that. We had 1000 people, including the local fire brigade, who took the knee. We, including police officers,
Dr. Gurnam Singh 55:38
taking the knee,
Rahul Patel 55:39
taking the knee, right? Okay. And previously, whenever we organize protests, there's always kind of the the police being unhappy about it and all that. At that time, they they were not unhappy with what was taking place, but the the sense of the force about the injustice that occurred was so big that it kind of continued, but let me just just also also say say this: in 2018, we talked about the Windrush generation and the injustice. Again, this square was important. That on that it was in fact April, and I remember this was 18th of April, and I helped organize this. This was a protest against the Home Secretary at that time, Amber Rudd, against the injustice she was she and the Conservative government had mounted against the Windrush generation. Again, we had filled the square. So this square is symbolically important. It acts as a process of activism; its symbolism in different ways attracts important processes of what's taking place. But just you say, and rightly say, that deaths haven't stopped. But just up the road, just over a mile here, Chris Kaba was murdered by the Metropolitan Police, just up here in Streatham, just up Brixton Hill, he was shot dead by the police. A police officer has been put on a charge. We don't know which way it will go. And then, just slightly off, we had the murder of Sarah Everard, just down the road as well. So this whole context about the police is not going away from this. It's an ongoing issue. In in that, I mean, the the murder of Sarah Everard was horrific in in the context. But you know, she wasn't black. She was a young white woman who was murdered by a police officer. So this whole kind of process hasn't stopped, hasn't ended, and we don't see Windrush Square or Brixton as a kind of a place where history has been sorted. History has been now finished. This is the past. It is an ongoing struggle in terms of what's what's taking place.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 57:59
Absolutely, and you know, I was wanting to maybe just to ask you to end by reflecting on Brixton today. What does Brixton mean today?
Rahul Patel 58:10
For for me, Brixton has offered me my life. I mean, just across the square, if we look across the square, we see a McDonald's. Above McDonald's,
Dr. Gurnam Singh 58:21
some people say that Brixton's becoming gentrified.
Rahul Patel 58:24
Oh yeah, I'll come to the gentrification. But let me just give an explanation. Just above McDonald's was Lambeth's Education Centre. At the at the age of 10, my mother and father brought to me. This was three days after we came to this country as as immigrants, refugees, whatever we were called at that time, and I was enrolled in the in in in my primary school again, not mile away from here, on on South Lambeth Road, and within within a week of me enrolling in the class, I was asked to sit in 11 plus. I did not know what an 11 plus was. I duly failed because the British system of education was imperial, so imperial measurements. I was used to Africa in international coordination, the 10s rather than the twelves. I never heard of something called a guinea. It was it was it was shillings and dollars, or whatever, but but that set in train for me my life from Brixton, going to local schools, right, observing what's in fact taking place. But it's but for me, his Brixton represents a history of struggle, positive, negative, in terms of what's taking place. And gentrification, by the way, is occurring all over London, right? Of course, it's been highlighted here because activists are highlighting in the kind of the context what's in the kind of context that's occurring because globalist capitalism has come here. Of course, there is the issue of appropriation, so we have commercial companies. Is using the word Brixton as their kind of selling beer, selling song, selling film, all that sort of stuff. But there are still large number of black people still living in Brixton, are going to be living in Brixton, still going to schools in Brixton, and that is not going to be negated overnight. And what about the
Dr. Gurnam Singh 1:00:22
police here? I mean, are the relations with police now well better? I mean, or is there still? It's no different. It's no
Rahul Patel 1:00:30
different. It's not different. The stop in searches are increasing. The stop in search is what led to the uprising. Scarman said in his report, he didn't think that there was anything wrong with the stop and searching.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 1:00:45
Sorry, yeah.
Rahul Patel 1:00:46
You know that Scarman didn't think that you were making any was anything anything wrong with stop and searches, right? And stop and search was what what led. And there are calls
Dr. Gurnam Singh 1:00:57
to reintroduce some of that as well. There are calls to relax the kind of restrictions on stop and search.
Rahul Patel 1:01:03
Yeah, and we are very likely to get. We are going to get a new government. It's going to be a Labour government, and the Labour government has adopted every hook, line, and sinker of the Tory agenda, and that includes social policy. It includes a whole issue of of of racism. It's kind of you know maybe maybe said it said it deliberately or didn't say it deliberately or it was a loose tongue, but Keir Starmer, the leader of the Labour Party, when the Black Lives Matter movement was happening, he said this is a moment. We took it as him using that as the immediate moment, rather than a historical moment for change,
Dr. Gurnam Singh 1:01:44
and the irony is that you know some of the after the 81 riots, when we saw the first trickle of black MPs entering Parliament, we have Diane Abbott, who currently is suspended from the Labour Party pending some kind of investigation for racism, anti-Semitism. So this is an irony that we've got.
Rahul Patel 1:02:07
And in some senses, we can use the word irony, but it is not. It is not that for someone who has been an anti-racist activist all their life to be accused of anti-Semitism. And I, I remember Diane Abbott fighting tooth and nail on every issue to do with anti-Semitism, and activists to be blurred and and to be scarred with that is is something that the right wing always use, and we have to be really clear that the right wing will try and appropriate our words of oppression, our words against oppression, for their own narration, and that's what's taking place around the world at the at the moment. The right wing phenomena of from Trump, Viktor Orban to what's taking place in India, to what's taking place in Turkey, what's taking place in Egypt? What is fundamentally taking place? It's you know in Israel in in in in in in that kind of form, but it's been raised to the top. So we we as kind of a pedagogic process have to discuss all of that. We have to put that in our learning processes because even in our own universities at the moment, we've been told we cannot talk about oppression. We cannot talk about what has been done to Palestinian people, what's been done to black people. It is seen as woke culture, cultural culture wars, etc. And I think, as as educationists, we have to be steady fast in making sure that they don't take that away from us. And I think returning back to Brixton, it was so important that Bernard Coard, and you know he was in North London, but his books were his publication was so well read here that educationists put their mark in saying we are not going to let our generations be reduced to non-human beings because that's what the educational system was about before.
Dr. Gurnam Singh 1:04:15
So we have to connect the past with the present. We have to connect the local with the global, and we also have to uncover oppression, but also archive resistance, because it's out of resistance that we can then have some hope. Thank you very much.